Home > Bollywood > Gloat away!

Gloat away!

Friday, April 13, 2012

Everytime a bad film becomes a hit—Housefull 2 being the latest example—the makers go about gloating that they know the audience and critics don’t. But every critic admits that there are some films that are meant for the brain-deficient, possibly illiterate kinds who don’t read reviews. And nobody ever said audiences have to go by critics’ ratings. Even if the critic-proof films never win awards or make it to any hall of fame.  But of course, the ‘laughing to the bank’ kinds don’t seem to understand that money can be lost, but a reputation for great artistry cannot be taken away.  Satyajit Ray films didn’t get bank-busting box-office revenues, but he is still know as India’s greatest filmmaker.

Anyway, the issue of what-do-critics-know comes up each time.  Returning to a piece written earlier in answer to this.  What the commercial filmmakers want is that their films should be unconditionally adored, and critics come in the way of the publicity hype that declares every film a magnum opus before its release and a blockbuster afterwards.  The conscientious critic is a bubble in the rarified air of self congratulation and mutual back-slapping that the industry loves to breathe in.

They are, of course, entitled to their views, but the quality of comment or criticism obviously depends on the quality of the work presented. And if week after week, films that emerge from Bollywood (or the Mumbai Film Industry) are mediocre at best; they can hardly expect anybody to stand up and applaud!   And if reviews and so abhorrent to them, then why are three and four star ratings proudly displayed in the ads?

The lay audience is really not too concerned about the quality of the film,   most just want 'timepass' which even a terrible film can sometimes provide. But there is a section that would read informed criticism and then see the film with a different perspective, and not just as a passive viewer.    Not everyone wants to chuck the film out of their minds along with the ticket stub.

By saying that they care more for ticket sales that criticism, filmmakers are themselves admitting that their work is more commerce than art.   Of course, box-office success is a desirable aim, but isn't the placing of cinema as an art form deserving of meaningful analysis (which admittedly cannot always happen in instant newspaper reviews) also an equally important goal?  Posterity may or may not count box-office collections, but will remember quality when it does make its rare appearance. And who will record that event? Certainly not the mass audience that the filmmaker woos so assiduously, instead of pursuing that elusive quality.

That said,  James Cameron once famously demanded that Kenneth Turan, the critic of the Los Angeles Times be sacked because he panned Titanic, so was obviously not in tune with popular taste, to which Turan is reported to have said, "I'm sorry, but we're not supposed to be applause meters. If you wanted to go to a restaurant for a special occasion and someone said, 'Why not go to McDonalds's ? More people go there than any other place,' would that really be enough to convince you?"

Facebook   Delicious   Delicious   submit to reddit reddit
COMMENTS
No Comments Posted
POST YOUR COMMENTS
Name:  
Email:    
Comments:
 
Hollywood
'The Artist', 'Hugo' in tie with five Oscars ...
Indian composer A.R. Rahman performed at the 84th
The roll of honour Here is the full ...
When I don’t experience an orgasm during a sexual
Dr. Rajan B. Bhonsle, M.D. (Bom)
Consulting Sex Therapist & Counsellor
Dr. (Mrs.) Minnu R. Bhonsle, Ph.D.
Consulting Psychotherapist & Counsellor
Astrology
Select Sun sign:
 
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)All business problems will be sorted out and cleared for steady progress. You will be able to accomplish all you desire limited only by your own aspirations. With a pocketful of money you will have a feeling of satisfaction and achievement. If you have been thinking of a new project now is the right time to begin when finance ceases to be a problem.
Tarot for Love
Select Sun sign:
 
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)What the cards say: Nothing will be gained by fretting Path: Understand and control your emotions. Don’t be reckless. Don’t take high risks Ally: Libra will listen… Avoid critical Virgo who will find faults Card for the week: Tarot key no. II The High Priestess. Look and turn inwards and understand your real needs and connect with them. Living on the surface may not give you the satisfaction that you seek
- Advertising -
While good monsoons will undoubtedly help the nat
Gold surged to a high of Rs 29770, quite close to
It might be too early for distributors to rejoice
Read More