Afternoon D & C Dedicated To Mumbai
Home > Culture > On Your Marx

On Your Marx

Tuesday, October 17, 2017
By Deepa Gahlot

About four years ago, Manoj Shah directed a play called 'Karl Marx In Kalbadevi', written by Uttam Gada and performed by Satchit Puranik. Inspired by Howard Zimm’s 1999 play 'Karl Marx in Soho', it is about what the title indicates – Marx coming down to earth and ending up at the hub of Mumbai’s business district in Kalbadevi.

The play was a hit in Gujarati, and later came out in an 'Hinglish' version to reach a wider audience. If Marx were to return to clear all misconceptions about his politics, and visits Mumbai, what better landing place could he find than Kalbadevi – where capitalism is pursued without any qualms.
Manoj Shah has almost made a career out of biographical plays about saints or literary figures. This time, tongue firmly in cheek, he embarked on a audacious production to deliver a sermon on socialism to incontrovertible capitalists and makes it entertaining, with just one actor holding the audience’s attention for the 90-odd minutes he is on stage.

Uttam Gada strings factoids about Marx together with homespun wisdom, occasional myth-busting (Marx’s religion is the opiate of the masses line was quoted out of context), some intellectual challenging and a lot of humour, in which director Manoj Shah is often referred to as Marx’s guide in the gullies of Kalbadevi, where a rich meal at the famous Bhagat Tarachand is fraught with some guilt and a pied a terre in a crowded chawl reminds Marx of his early days of poverty, struggle and the writing of the tome 'Das Capital'.

If there is a problem with the play, it’s that there is too much Karl Marx, family and friends, and too little Kalbadevi.  There’s plenty in those crowded rabbit hutch business establishments, temples, old tenements, eateries and constant bustle for a communist to comment on.

It’s undoubtedly too simplistic, but then, a complex analysis of Marxist philosophy or its relevance in today’s greed-is-good era would perhaps have been too much for the target audience. The world will commemorate Marx’s birth anniversary in 2018, so any work about him and his life, work and ideology is welcome. His immense contribution to society, economics and politics still needs to be studied and debated. An enjoyable play could well be the starting point.

No Comments Posted
Maha Poll
We never object... it’s only during the festival ...
I am a 25-year-old man working in a call centre i
Dr. Rajan B. Bhonsle, M.D. (Bom)
Consulting Sex Therapist & Counsellor
Dr. (Mrs.) Minnu R. Bhonsle, Ph.D.
Consulting Psychotherapist & Counsellor
Select Sun sign:
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)Old, fond memories will define your mood today, which will show up in the manner in which you deal with work, where your mellow side will be visible to others. You are also circumspect with money and tend towards saving it. Ganesha says people dealing in cash and money-lenders will benefit.
- Advertising -
For a very long time now, both Law and Management
Writer, educator and moderator Kartik Bajoria wri
Covestro, the global manufacturer of high-perform
Read More