Afternoon D & C Dedicated To Mumbai
Home > Business & Investment > Compulsion in equity investing

Compulsion in equity investing

Monday, January 09, 2017
By Jayant Pai

Jayant Pai
CFP and Head - Marketing, PPFAS Mutual Fund

You may remember the time when, as children, you were forced by your parents to eat your vegetables. When you quizzed them for a reason, they simply said "Well, you MUST eat them because they are good for you". Today, stockmarket 'experts' have taken the place of parents, by screaming to all within earshot that everyone's investment portfolio MUST contain equities. They lament that Indian investors do not know what is good for them. That is why, equities (including equity mutual funds) comprise only around four per cent of their portfolios.

They chide them for choosing gold, real estate and fixed income instruments, implying time and again that none of these possess the one magical quality that stocks apparently possess and that is, the ability to provide 'real returns' on a sustained basis. Some are also adamant that investors will 'be compelled' to invest in stocks. Despite so much advocacy for equity, why have Indian investors not flocked en-masse to the stockmarkets? Here are a few probable reasons:

Delayed feedback mechanism:
All investors would like clarity on two things - (A) The returns that they can expect (B) The downside that they are likely to suffer. In case of investments other than equities, either the expected returns are known in advance or the volatility of returns is locked in a tight range.

Unfortunately, stocks do not offer comfort on both these aspects.

It ain't the numbers alone: While I believe that one can choose any sample set to prove one's point, it is a fact that there are several studies that show that stocks have outperformed many other asset classes over long periods of time.

However, this alone is not enough. While a rational investor may be convinced by such statistics, real-world investors are more emotional than rational. To most, investing is much more than mere numbers.

The 'touchy-feely' aspect:
For many investors, the term 'investment' should connote something 'solid'. A gold bar or an apartment provides that solidity. We could extend this to the figurative solidity provided by a fixed deposit with any Government owned bank. Unfortunately, to many, stocks are mere pieces of paper. In other words, you exchange one piece of paper (that is, money) for another. Now with demat accounts, even this piece has been replaced by a book entry. Also, it is likely that one may suffer monetary losses even if one purchases the stocks of 'blue-chip' companies. Hence, solid companies need not necessarily be 'safe-and-solid investments', unless one has impeccable timing.

The trust factor:
Stockmarket 'experts' often counter the above apprehension by saying that stocks must be held for the long-term. But time frames of short, medium and long are too nebulous for most investors. Besides, there is a feeling that often, advice from such 'experts' lacks accountability. Also, they notice that most of the talking heads advocating investment in stocks are associated with the stockmarket in some form or the other, be it as brokers, money managers, investment bankers etc.

Lack of peer pressure:
Investors are often driven by the 'Herd Mentality'. If your friends and acquaintances have been making money in gold and real estate and 'preserving' their capital in fixed deposits and bonds, you would prefer to follow them rather than be the outlier in the group. The implicit pressure exerted by your peer group, has a big impact on your investment psyche. It certainly is far more influential than some stranger extolling the virtues of stocks.

Predictably incorrect:
Just as economists have failed to predict most of the recessions, for the past decade (at least since 2004), gold and real estate bears have often predicted crashes that did not happen. On the other hand, investors have witnessed at least three big falls in the stock market (2006, 2008 and 2011), the impressive point-to-point increase notwithstanding.

All this does not mean that Indian investors will shun equities forever. The current nibbling may increase to a bite-sized chunk in due course. However, this may happen due to more mundane asset allocation considerations, rather than the 'compulsion' that many experts so glibly suggest.

No Comments Posted
City news
Activist had sought information from the MMRCL ab
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) is n
The blue whale falls in the red list ...
I want to take up the career in 'Psychology'. My
Dr. Rajan B. Bhonsle, M.D. (Bom)
Consulting Sex Therapist & Counsellor
Dr. (Mrs.) Minnu R. Bhonsle, Ph.D.
Consulting Psychotherapist & Counsellor
Select Sun sign:
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)
Aries (Mar 21 - Apr 20)Your convincing powers are so great that you can even convince people to do what they don't want to do. Today these powers will bear remarkable results. You realise the need to improve your home and your personality. Ganesha says today you will take some concrete steps in this direction.
- Advertising -
You’ve made up your mind; it is time to jump out
We often find ourselves hunched over a keyboard o
Most of us measure success by the programming we
Read More